More American Idol

Oct 2 2009 07:00 PM ET

Adam Lambert vs. Susan Boyle: Which Nov. 24 record release has you more excited?

Ding, ding, ding, ding! Ladies and gentlemen, let’s get ready to rummmmblllle…or at least get ready to mark Nov. Read the full post.

Comments (740 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 26
  • trennie

    Susan Boyle is a unique talent who will top the charts for years. Contemporary. No. Timeless. And what is a Michael Slezak? Possibly a rare form of insect life. Certainly not a knowledgeable music critic.

    • hahahaha

      LMAO!!!

      You WERE being sarcastic, right?

    • Tagrid

      Clearly you’ve never seen Slezak’s 3 part interview with Adam. Whatever. Your loss.

      Obviously if you think SB is “Timeless.” you perfer her over Adam – which is your perogotive. But remember, her debut album is covers. SB is, and always will be, a cover singer. Period.

      • Edie

        I don’t see how their cd’s can be compared musicly if SB is cover & AL is original. Amazon is now offering both their cd’s in one purchase. Good sales ploy IMO. If AL doesn’t get fed up by this stupid PR and quit, he will be it.

  • Dave

    Adam Lambert for sure…dude has some pipes…looking forward to his music…

  • Jay

    Definitely Adam but I wish Susan well too. I might check out her CD in Dec.

  • PJ

    I voted for Adam in the poll, but I have already pre-ordered both on Amazon. I did not pre-order Kris Allen, but did pre-order Allison’s which debuts the first week of December.

  • trennie

    Susan Boyle is the most exciting singer to come along in 20 years. She may have been discoveredd late but she’ll be around long afterthe latest flavor of tthe month is gone.

    • michelle

      I cant even imagine what kind of personality you have if you think Susan Boyle is excititng..no comparison between her and Adam, Adam is the package deal, looks, voice, stage presence, charisma etc… the only thing susan has is a pleasant voice, shes definitely not a “whole package” !!SORRY BUT TRUE !!

      • PWattis

        Hmm, I can’t imagine what kind of personality you have to reply in such a way.

  • countyjo

    actually i am more excited to get jason castro’s album

    • DNW

      ewwwww

  • arlene boden

    Susan Boyle hands down. Her voice is just magnificent. I could listen to her forever. The lady has a huge heart,with a beautiful personality to match. Can’t wait for her album. Everyone I know will be buying it. God bless her. Arlene

  • Jo

    Susan has a good voice but not current. Adam is not even from this planet. His voice is otherwordly and there’s no question in my mind that he will be iconic.

    • GinaBallerina

      Well-said! I’m so proud to be his fan. He makes music exciting again. : )

    • TheWho

      DON’T JINX IT :/

      I do want to see him blow up though, that would be epic.

      My dad hates Idol but he said Adam COULD be iconic in pop like Britney, Beyonce, Gaga etc. IF he has the right songs. It ALL depends on the music. Justin aside, it’s been fkn ages since we’ve had a male “popstar”…

  • Abby

    Susan by far. voice of an angel

    • terie

      @Abby: Susan does have a lovely voice but ADAM can sing any song that she can sing as well … he too has the voice of an angel.

    • Angel

      Listen to ADAM’s Brigadoon’s ‘Come To Me Bend To Me. That’s how an angel sings.

  • LisaH

    I’m not going to diss Susan because I have to admit that I have never watched her YouTube videos. Therefore, I can’t judge her. Adam, on the other hand, I have watched over and over and over…I can’t remember the last time I was this excited about an album (or even the single — WHEN are we going to hear one?????).

  • Nina

    How is this even question? Susan Boyle has a lovely voice, but I wouldn’t pay a dime to see her live. Adam Lambert is the most phenomenally exciting entertainer to come on the scene in years…and can EASILY sing rings around Ms. Boyle. No doubt he’ll put out extraordinary music videos, and have a live tour like no other. Can. Not. Wait!

  • Minnie

    Slezak, the more important question is why is Jive screwing Kris over in favor of Allison?? Nice cover shot of her single they’ve given her, while they completely ignored Kris’s single with a cover that doesn’t even have his picture on it. Seems like they’re banking on Allison big time! Where’s the outrage and story over Kris’s treatment??

    • Chris

      Why are you here commenting on Kris, Geez this has nothing to do with that loser.

  • bajaraquel

    Both have beautiful voices yet I see Susan appealing to a much larger audience around the world. Best of luck to both.

  • Lin

    Lambert cannot easily “sing rings around” Susan Boyle. He is good, but he is loud and grating a lot of the time. Boyle has a phenomenol voice and she even has one without music to back her up! I thought the guy who won American Idol when Lambert was on was better than Lambert. I dont get tired of listening to Boyle…I do get tired of Lambert, and yes, I do like him. As for the posters who have not listened to Boyle, you are missing out.

    • terie

      I’m afraid it is you who are missing out if you did not/have not heard ADAM’S rendition of Come To Me Bend To Me from Brigadoon or The Prayer a duet with Ilysia Pierce. Try looking them up on Youtube and then make that statement again. If you can then you do not know of what you speak!!!

      • Matt

        Not true Cath. Alot of people DON’t think that. If you are going by his win on Idol. Ok. But if you go by how well received his album is going, without any help from anyone but his fans, then YOUR WRONG.

    • Hendrix

      You thought Kris was better than Adam? Umm, ok lol. You could barely hear him in their Queen duet with Brian May.

      He had to pull out of his own concert because he was ill, first time ever an Idol winner has done that. When Adam and Kris duetted on Crazy at Ford Day, Kris sang like a drunk baby. Seriously, he was slurring and out of breath LOL WTF. His studio recordings all sound literally the same but he has that emotional catch in his voice that teen girls love. And he’s too sly/naive when it comes to music. I remember when he said on Idol he wanted to take an original song and make it his own then he took Adele’s EXACT arrangement of Make You Feel My Love and stood there as the judges praised him on his “originality”.

      • Cathleen

        Evidently a lot of people think Kris is better than Adam.

    • Lisa

      Susan has a nice voice but she is not a Barbara Streisand or even an Eva Cassidy.

  • arlene boden

    Susan Boyle is so talented, I could just listen and listen to her beautiful voice. She is also a lovely person too. I and my family just loved watching her on T.V. With all the questions that have been thrown at her on various T.V. shows and interviews,she always remains poised and quite natural. Her answers are right on the mark,and she makes it look like she is sitting in her own home, talking with friends. Very smooth for someone who hasn’t ever been put on the spot like this.Susan you are a natural. We love you,and cannot wait for your album to come out. Arlene and family

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 26
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP