The 2010 CMA Awards nominations came out yesterday, and despite nine well-deserved nominations for Miranda Lambert, including Entertainer of the Year, most of the chatter was Read the full post.
Sep 2
2010
04:15 PM ET
Carrie Underwood: Why do the CMAs keep snubbing her for Entertainer of the Year?
- Comments 740
- Add comment
Latest News
- 'American Idol': Season 11 winner is...
- 'Revenge': Replay Gabriel Mann's live chat
- 'Idol' Top 2: Rate the debut singles
- 'Great Gatsby' trailer's 'Zeigfeld' folly
- 'Men in Black 3': EW movie review
- 'G.I. Joe: Retaliation' pushed to 2013
- 'On the Road': EW movie review at Cannes
- 'Moonrise Kingdom': EW movie review








She is the best–and most successful–Idol winner to date. And I bet the CMAs hold that against her.
. Carrie is #1 solo artist this year. no one has shined more brightly then carrie. 3 out of 3 singles released has garnered much success-all making to #1 on COUNTRY charts. only 1 out of 3 singles miranda released has made it to #1. carrie had one of the biggest tours ever and reviews ravished about how entertaining and how carrie is truly a country superstar. She can sing anything at anytime anywhere and can write and play instruments too. didn’t know that? well don’t say things you know not . Of course, sales don’t necessarily mean that you are THE entertainer but you can’t put it against carrie. 1.8 million albums already sold just FYI. Carrie’s already headlined 2 MASSIVELY successful tours while miranda was still opening for other people. Carrie has developed into a super star while as talented as miranda is is just a star.
I don’t think carrie being snub has a lot to do with the whole “two female artist can’t be nominated at same time”. after the whole fiasco with the taylor swift scooping it all-cma knew they need another booster for ratings and so didn’t want to just give carrie the nomination and WIN that she deserved. so who was there to stand and compete against carrie? there really wasn’t anyone so CMA, after ignoring miranda for years tries to make “amends” by oversaturating her and putting other nominees who wasn’t even half as successful as carrie or half as matured as a country singer so it won’t appear as if they were using miranda just as an excuses to SNUB and USE carrie. CMA is just greedy and full of politics. they’re just using carrie for ratings (thus giving her the hand in hosting) but not even giving her justly deserved nominations. carrie should just have said NO. but seeing how carrie is-she will still do it regardless because she loves the country community so much. I don’t like how they’re just using carrie’s character to MANIPULATE. SHAME ON CMA.
The EOTY award is supposed to be looking at the artist achievements between July 1, 2009 & June 30, 2010. Now look at the people who are in the category. Shouldn’t Carrie be in that group too? Yes, she should!! I’m not taking anything away from Miranda…she has had a very good year, but I do think that the CMAs has snubbed Carrie..there is no doubt about that. I will only watch the show in November because Carrie is co-hosting. I don’t think that Carrie should always win every award, but she deserves EOTY. Next year CMAs should pay more attention to what is going on in country music.
CARRIE UNDERWOOD IS AMAZING AND PEOPLE ARE JUST PLAN STUPID OF THEY DONT SEE THAT ! I MEAN SHE WON EOTY AT THE ACM’S TWICE ! HELLO ! SHES OBVS AMAZING ! AND I THINK THE CMA PEOPLE KNOW THAT SHE’LL WIN SO THEY DONT NOMINATE HER ! SHEEESH PEOPLE NEED TO OPEN THEIR EYES !!!!!! ok im dont now bye.
It is ridiculous. Miranda, Lady A, and Zac Brown Band? Over Carrie? Really. I hope Brad wins now.
Whitney: THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU! You said everything we Carrie fans wanted to say, but better. I really appreciate you taking the time to defend Carrie and point out all the reasons she should have been considered for EOTY. I had previously thought you were not a big fan of Carrie, but I was wrong, and I owe you an apology for that.
Carrie totally deserved the nomination long ago, and I do think it is a combination of elitism to snub her for coming from American Idol, as well as jealousy that she has done so well, when maybe the voters’ favorites have not faired as well.
But for a major news publication such as Entertainment Weekly to finally say, what should have been said long ago, has made me feel so much better. I was feeling pretty anry and down yesterday about Carrie’s snub, as I honestly wonder what on earth the voters expect Carrie to do if they think she hasn’t deserved it yet? She has headlined two major, successful tours that got great reviews (especially the recent Play On tour), and she writes many of her own songs now. She plays both piano and guitar every night on stage (contrary to the misinformed allegations of her haters here who have no clue what they are talking about),she sells a ton of albums, does great on country radio with all number 1 hits, and has been a great ambassador for country music.
CMA VOTERS: CARRIE UNDERWOOD IS THE REASON I GREW TO LOVE COUNTRY MUSIC AS SHE INTRODUCED ME TO IT ON AMERICAN IDOL. So give her some credit for expanding the minds of many of us rock and pop fans, who now love country music and buy albums of other artists too such as Miranda, Brad, Keith Urban, etc. Carrie got me to give the genre another chance, and it is because of her that I am now a proud country fan. You go girl, Carrie! We love you even if the crotchety CMA voters snub you!
Thanx again, Whitney. Your article really made me feel better about everything, even if Carrie is snubbed again next year. lol
Ditto for me, I started on country music because of Carrie, and have started buying albums by Martina, Reba, Jason Aldean, Taylor, Miranda, Lady A and Brad. Before her time, I don’t even know who these people are, except for Martina.
To the haters: CARRIE PLAYS GUITAR AND PIANO EVERY SINGLE NIGHT ON TOUR, EVEN BETTER THEN TAYLOR. SHE ALSO COWROTE 7 SONGS ON HER NEW ALBUM. So please stop with your ignorant lies that she doesn’t play an instrument or write her own songs. Big lie. She took piano lessons for over 8 years, and guitar as well. She is writing many of her own songs, and 6 songs she wrote have already hit number 1 I believe. So take your invalid arguments elsewhere. Carrie is a very talented musician, songwriter, and performer, not just a great vocalist.
Adding to your comment, Taylor learnt the guitar from a tv repairman (it was on TS trivia)… Also, all her songs can be played on the same basic chords. If saying that Taylor is a ‘great’ guitar player, then my 12 year old nephew must be Jimi Hendrix
I wish the CMAs had played her duet with Jason Aldean last night on the show, where she rocked out to Guns n Roses. She did even better then Jason, who I do love, and she would have put those snarky jaded voters all to shame when they saw how GREAT of a performer she really is. Carrie can jam to Guns n Roses almost as good as Axel Rose, and that is no lie. Why do people not know about this side of her? If more people did, they would see how much she has grown as a live performer since her days on Idol, when she was shy and reserved. Now, she has upped her game, improved her stage presence, and put on a tremendous live show that is getting great critical reviews all over the country. CMA voters: If you snubbed her for being on American Idol, you are both hypocrites and elitist snobs, since your darling Miranda LAmbert came from a reality show too, Nashville Star.
Don’t worry Carrie: WE LOVE YOU AND YOU ARE THE ENTERTAINER OF OUR YEAR, ALWAYS!!!
The big difference between AI & NS is that AI is based in LA, where country music is not as big.
It is an OUTRAGE for Carrie to not even be NOMINATED. It’s not about WINNING.. It’s about recognizing the achievements and hard work that Carrie had put in this last year. To not even be nominated is a HUGE slap in the face for Carrie. It’s like saying that what she has done for the past year (which is A LOT) is not enough.. So, what ZBB, LA, ML etc, has done is enough? LA was only an OPENING ACT, ML has only been touring for the LAST MONTH (small venues).. Whereas Carrie has headlined Stadium of Fire and sold-out arenas, garnered 3 out of 3 #1 singles from her recent album, sang at the Super Bowl (most watched in tv history), appeared on numerous tv programs/interviews, had her own tv special, HOSTED their very own CMA for 2 years! Tell me WHY she wasn’t nominated?!?!?! She fits everything in the criteria that CMA has stated. This is ridiculous. A BIG EFFIN’ JOKE!
I agree. It is unfortunate that they have been snubbing her all these years. If they feel she not worthy why ask her to host?
Thank you for this article by the way. Exactly what carrie fans everything are feeling right now.
It’s ridiculous. As others have said; it’s not about winning. It’s about the nomination. For them to not even award Carrie a nomination when she was all over the place during the eligibility period is horrific. It’s snubbing. They seem to be okay with her hosting for three years straight. They are fine with the fans she brought into country music due to her success. But she has now been around for two SOLO tours. Three CDs, all her songs have gone #1 in at least one format. She had a two hour solo special on television. She shows up to all the awards shows even when not winning; and performs. She earned a Entertainer of the Year nomination. I can almost understand last year since she was in the studio and not touring. But this year when she has a new CD. And has toured since the spring. And come on, in that special last night. She had 3 SONGS shown in the telecast. It’s ridiculous to snub. Whether she deserves to win is another question. She should have at least gotten the nomination. And if it’s because she was ACMA Entertainer of the Year award this year; that is plain stupid. They can still reward her… I am not sure it’s because she comes from a reality show I will give them the credit because Miranda placed THIRD in one. Even if it was a Nashville based one… Because penalizing her for coming from a talent show is ridiculous. But still, she has been very accepted for the start she had… I can’t get why she can host yet she can be awarded the nomination for Entertainer of the Year when she has been all over the place… And certainty earned it. And is current touring…
Carrie got ROBBED. I’ve too have seen her in concert. She is amazing. This article said something about overall contribution to the country music image. Um, Sounds like Carrie Underwood to me.
I am proud to be a country fan. I am even more proud to be a Carrie Underwood fan. I love her music, her professionalism, her work ethic, her openess about her faith, the way she loves and respects the county community and other artists. She is class, integrity and talent all rolled up in one. Not that she is the only one with those qualities. But she is one of the many country stars that does have those qualities. I don’t know what the voters wanted. I only know why I’m a fan of Mrs. Mike Fisher. Sure seems like a snub to me, but Carrie will be happy for those nominated and do her best to make the cmas a great show. And I will watch and cheer her on.
Fine post cr!!
Carrie has won many awards… She is doing fine.
I see country
music overall
with a lot of
problems…
So many names
have been over
looked…
Country music
just isn’t the real thing
anymore…and
their needs to
be boundaries
on what can
be put into
videos…
Carrie is very
adored for keeping good
values…That
is what really
matters..