More American Idol

Feb 13 2010 03:55 PM ET

Allison Iraheta, Adam Lambert, and Kris Allen: Awesome three ways in NYC

To folks who aren’t fluent in American Idol, there was probably zero appeal in the idea of Ryan Seacrest’s “Rock My Town” contest that brought Read the full post.

Comments (1074 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 24
  • barbls

    I am tired of you people calling Adam’s fans rude, etc. We waiting in the freezing cold for hours and on top of that we had to wait an extra hour and 15 minutes to get in. Allison was already performing. Some people that lived outside of the city needed to get home or were just plain exhausted. Standing not only outside, but for the whole concert. I wanted to stay, but had to leave due to another commitment cross town. It had nothing to do with Kris. I was dying to stay, but because it was running so late, I couldn’t. This obsession people have for dumping on Adam Fans is just plain jealousy. We are passionate about Adam. You other fans seem to be threatened by that and are always making nasty remarks. Talk about your love for Kris and leave us alone.

    • Mary

      So you are saying that you would of left after Kris set, because it was so late and cold, I think not.

      • Mary

        I meant to say if Kris was second. The point is stop making excuses. I for one would of loved to see all three, but I didn’t win tickets.

      • Lisa

        Mary did you even get off your ass to vote? If you didn’t quit blaming others. If you voted for Little Rock because Kris and his mommy wanted it there, again, your fault.

    • Elaine20

      Not buying it, Barbis. It’s funny how so many Adam fans managed to hang on…….just…..to…..the end of his…..set, but not a moment longer. Whew!

      • @Elaine20

        Why can’t the Glamberts leave when they want to leave? What the big deal? It a freaking free world or isn’t it? Many people are not prepared to stand there for another hour watching an artist they aren’t particularly fond of. I am not dissing Kris but I simply don’t like his music. It’s that simple! This entire concert was a very bad idea if you ask me.

      • Elaine20

        I`ve never said they should have been prevented from leaving. They were, as you said, free to prove their lack of consideration for others. We agree on one thing…the concert was a bad idea.

  • Allyriane

    Yes Adam Lambert is 11 feet tall. Not a petty small person who feeds Idol paranoia and fan wars by overstating fiction. Who polled the people exiting and determined they were all Glamberts? Who determined it was a THIRD which by eyewitness accounts are overstated…You? And Cantiello tweeted lame childish nonsense after Adam during the break because people were going for fresh air. FOUR freakin people fainted (not ONE, but yeah, saying ONE hides how uncomfortable it was in there so you mention ONE. Deceptive. Anyone who couldn’t or wouldn’t spend another hour STANDING IN A SAUNA do not owe Idol people any explanations. Personally, I’ll come and go where I please when I spend MY MONEY and MY TIME getting myself there. Thank God S8 is finally DONE. AND way to go pimping KA’s “excellent band” and ignoring Adam’s tremendous WORLD FAMOUS BAND; Monte from Madonna and Prong, Longineau from Yellowcard, and Justcallmehorse from Korn and several other internationally famous bands. Filling in for Lisa Harriton from Smashing Pumpkins. And Tommy from the Planet Fierce LOL. Such a Plaidbert you are. You guys live for the underdog narrative.

    • Cookie

      Thanks for your comment,Allyrianne. Someone I know who was there said it was evident that none of Kris’ musicians were not professional sounding, unlike Alison’s and Adam’s. And Kris had them TURN UP THE VOLUME TO BLAST his music. Maybe the fan who fainted got an epileptic seizure from it? He and the band apparently didnt stop when she fainted, and kept right on singing. I was told that Kris’ vocals were so poorly enunciated that one could hardly understand the words to his songs. This is the kind of idol America likes.

      • Cookie

        Sorry, I meant to say none of Kris’ musicians were professional sounding. Very average.

      • To Cookie

        I am an Adam fan and it’s unnecessary for you to diss Kris. I am going to watch Kris’ performances now and see if they were really as bad as you said they were. I really doubt you are correct because many people said he has improved a lot since Idol.

    • Jurnee

      Couldn’t agree more. I’m astounded coming here to read a review and see the childishness and bitterness of Kris fans. Unless people were at the concert (which I wasn’t, you don’t have a right to say anything. YOU weren’t the ones standing for hours in what sounds like horrible temperature extremes. No wonder people fainted and no wonder they had to get fresh air or leave after the second set. To somehow blame Adam for that or take it out on him is unbelievably petty.

  • danni

    Great article. I wish Iwas there. I also think it might be good for them to tour the first year together. I hate to think anyone left after Adam on purpose. That is just wrong. I am a die hard Adam fan, but I would never do that.

    • Allyriane

      Until you take a bus at 9 am to get there in the afternoon, stand in line freezing cold for hours, have to wait another 1.5 hours inside in a SAUNA with 4 people fainting STANDING UP WITH NO SEATS, then hang around another 1.5 hours for set changes, you actually have NO IDEA what you’d “do”. Some people were in that around the building line outside so long they missed the beginning of Allison who started without them.

      • Elaine20

        Yup, I know what I wouldn’t do, in any case. Everyone knew what time the doors opened, and if they chose to wait in line all day like kids, and then couldn’t show Kris the consideration of staying a mere 45 minutes longer, then they should perhaps think twice next before taking tickets from someone who would have loved at least two of the performers, and would have stayed for ALL out of common courtesy.

      • @Elaine20

        You can whine all you want but it’s a free world and people can do what they freaking want to do. I don’t see any problem with people leaving before Kris’ set. Many probably didn’t want to watch his performances. Does it really matter???

      • Elaine20

        It only matters if it bothers them to be thought of as rude. I think Kris has become accustomed to it, unfornutely.

      • Lisa

        @Elaine……If Kris cannot handle a few people not staying for his set then he should find another career. It won’t be the last time that someone will have to leave during one of his concerts. The problem is Kris’s fans are so whiny.

      • elaine20

        Lisa, I don’t think Kris’s fans being “whiny” are the subject of this review.

        What was mentioned in Slezak’s actual review was that 1/3 of the crowd left. The Lambert fans have shown so much animosity towards Kris, in almost every comments section of any article I’ve read, that I would feel pretty confident in saying that those that left were Lambert fans. According to 4 Idol journalists that were there, it happened. I think it’s rude. That’s all. I won’t call you names, or generalize about the Lambert fans. I’m just saying that in my OWN opinion, the ones that left were rude.

  • Mary

    I agree with Alycia,Slezak is trying to fuel the flames between the fans. Only a number left and some of them tweeted that they had to catch trains, etc. I wish people would use some common sense when reading info from the media. We all that the media has only one purpose in mind.

    • Kev

      I don’t know how many left, but obviously it was enough that even people on twitter remarked about it. The point being, If Adam was last would these people have left, probably not. It shows no class, and if they only wanted to see Adam, fine- go to his solo concert and leave the tickets for fans that appreciates all three.

      • Allyriane

        It became a twitter issue from CANTIELLO who tweeted childish accusations immediately after Adam’s set. Get the facts.

      • Kev

        Allyriane- I do have the facts. Cantiello was not the only one commenting on it. The point is stop making excuses for poor behavior.

      • @Kev

        It’s a free world dude. People can come and go as they wish. They simply didn’t want to watch Kris for obvious reasons. What’s wrong with that? Now coming back to be class, maybe you should educate some of your younger Kris friends who are outright RUDE!!!

  • Vada

    I don’t hate Adam. His fans are another matter.

    • Anne

      Well please refrain from lumping us all in together. Every artist has some not so desirable fans but that doesn’t include all of the fanbase or even a large portion of it and that includes Kris.

    • nellie

      His fans don’t care whether u like them or not. they don’t know u. Adam doesn’t know u. infact kris that u are fighting for on every single blog, article or video doesn’t know u either.

  • jessie

    I find it really strange that after a stellar performance by all 3 idols, that people insist on focusing their attention on the fact that a group of attendees left before the final act! Not much talk about how epic these 3 performed, but only about how rude it was that some left before Kris performed. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure out that those who are complaining are offended because they are fans of Kris and want to blame Adam and his fans for what they believe hurt their boys feelings.

    • media bias

      NO, blame Cantiello and Sleazak for starting it with the bs. Cantiello was trashing “glamberts” immediately after adam’s set. typical media nonsense. IDGAF it’s over thank GOD.

    • Elaine20

      Yup. I’m sure if you took time to really think about it, you’d want some respect for your guy, too.

  • itiswhatitis

    Imma bad fan, I could care less about their fanbases.Kris & Adams fans spend way to much time over who shoulda coulda won. I just care about the music. Allison is outa this world crazy singer. I cant even believe a human can hit notes like Adam. Kris is a great singer as well, just a different style than the other 2. He fits the AI “role” well.

  • Deen

    This is RIDICULOUS. Two talented artists who are nice, decent people, and who are FRIENDS, and each one seems to have a cadre of nasty, name-calling fans who think that trashing the other guy is what you have to do to be a loyal fan.

    If you don’t like one of them, FINE. I’m not challenging anyone’s personal taste. But can you drop the rudeness, for God’s sake? Neither one of these guys deserves fans like this.

  • Mary

    Well Slezak, once again, you managed to keep stirring your pot!

  • Carole

    This is Music, not Junior High. I personally would prefer that they didn’t tour together because of the fan crap. ALL of the haters need to be completely ignored. If you let them in that window, you give them way too much power! I loved all three sets, it was like getting the PuPu platter, something to satisfy every craving!

    • Cheyenne

      Love it, Carole, I always order the Pu Pu platter. I like the sweet and sour wings the most, but the fried won tongs, the shrimp, the beef sticks-all wonderful!

      And I love all three of these talented artists. I think people should just concentrate on the positives, praise and support the artist they love, and ignore the rest. Life is too short to waste with this kind of garbage.

      PS Did I mention I like the sweet and sour wings the most? Don’t hate me.

  • SweetTart

    I would truly love to see Kradison if only the ticktets could be distributed evenly to every fan group [maybe through their offical sites,?!]. Certainly people would find ways around it, but it would provide a filter for all of the Glitter Cows and the manure they leave behind.

    • Angelraj

      Wow, what a nasty and classless remark! I’m sure yo are quite taken with your cleverness, but that was a completely trashy thing to say.

    • DillonsDad

      SweetTart – I have to agree with Angelraj, yours was a seriously rude and undeserved comment. I don’t understand all the hating going on here.

    • Allyriane

      Ha Ha and you don’t have to worry about seeing Kradison. Tin hatting is over. There is no Kradison it’s an illusion. Or haven’t you noticed your boy KA was a no show at Adam’s birthday and every significant event since the tour was over. LMAO who GAF? Worry about buying Kris’s album. It’s in trouble JSYK.

    • shelby

      sweet-tart, honey, based on album sales alone, Kris and Allison would’ve been playing to a near empty venue had it not been for the glitter cows you so hatefully mock.

      Face facts, Adam was the draw on the AI tour, Adam was the draw for this concert. Adam should’ve gone last. period.end.of.story. Then kris fans could’ve left and clucked about how they walked out on Adam’s set.

      • Elaine20

        Yup, you said it shelby. Adam should have gone last, and damn it, Kris must pay!!!! eleventy!!!

      • Molly

        Susan Boyle > Adam Lambert.

        His promotion was out of this world ridiculous and he’s what? Gone gold in three months? That’s not that great. David Cook was platinum by this time last year and really he didn’t make too much of a splash, so I can’t understand the justification that Adam Lambert is taking the world by storm. It’s more of a short mist really. It’s not hating on him, but I read about these unrealistic expectations and justifications for his level of success it’s annoying frankly!

      • jun

        Molly, gold (album) in three months is really, really good especially when comparing it with his fellow Season8′ers and other artists. And about David Cook, what happen to him? If you’re not a fan of Adam, you need not worry about his future. I assure you his fans are very satisfied with the album & what’s going on with his career right now. He lived up to their expectations and he’s taking their world by storm.

      • Nick

        I want to know this, Elaine20 do you have a life? I mean you are all over the place. You are not saying anything new, you repeat yourself often and you are making an azz of yourself. If you are representing of a Kris fan I feel sorry for the guy.

      • elaine20

        Say what you want, Nick. I’ve had some free time the past few days, and when I’ve seen a comment I’m interested in, I respond. I have not been reduced to name calling like many others, so what’s your problem? How can I be representative of a Kris fan? I am one person, and represent only myself in these discussions. Get over it.

    • WTF

      Sweettart! That was the worst I’ve read here!!! Kris must really love having you as a fan!! BTW your mom is probably fat and old too!!!!!! Wait until it’s your turn!!!

  • Virginia

    This concert was absolutely epic. One of the very most memorable of the many dozens I have seen over the past 30 years. It was simply amazing!

    I will see anything Adam does, Allison too, and I’ll root Kris on because I think he’s wonderful even though his style isn’t my favorite among them.

    I would love to see them tour together, but at some point I definitely want to see Adam tour solo. Though preferably not as the opening act for some other group I’ll have to pay a fortune because of and not be interested in seeing. If he opened for someone I was interested in like Bowie or Gaga or Madge, that would be fine. But I’d still rather see him solo, in a small adult-only venue where he could let go and be himself to his heart’s content.

    • Virginia

      Let me restate that: I don’t think I’d like to see them tour together, but an occasional reunion concert like this could be a lot of fun, for us and them.

      • Mandy

        Virgina, I actually had a connection who was able to get me a VIP ticket to this Kradison concert, but I turned it down. I went to 3 idol concerts and couldn’t stand having to sit through all the other idols just to see Adam for 20 minutes. I went to Gridlock and am going to his solo Fantasy Springs concert and am so excited. There are a few tickets left (over 3K sold out of 3500 available), so if you can fly out to Palm Springs that would be great. I’ll also go to the one in Richmod, BC on 4/9. Tickets go on sale 2/18.

      • Kev

        Mandy – at least your honest about it and left the ticket for someone else. I think that is the point people are trying to make here. If you don’t like all three artist, let someone who does go.

  • media bias

    Sleazak you’re so transparent. ONE THIRD LEFT? How convenient. Oh shock there were three singers so I guess it was all the ONE THIRD guy’s people who left. Because of course the show was divided into equal thirds of fans right? Exactly one third for KA one third for AI and one third for AL. If Kris Allen fans are so freaking passionate then why didn’t they show up in droves there? NYC has about 8 million people he couldn’t fill up a 500 seat venue? Oh was that because all the votes came from Arkansas where they apparently don’t like to travel? Did his FAMILY even attend? And BTW that’s the same crowd that are keeping him the lowest selling Idol in history. Way to go FANS. Wont even buy the album just the freaking single. HRMPH.

    • Deen

      A few corrections. As others have pointed out, there was a 20 minute intermission after Adam and that place was hot and stifling. A lot of people flooded outside but most of them came back in before Kris started. Also, Kris is not the lowest-selling Idol. He had the worst first week, but his album has sold steadily since then. And please get past the idea that Arkansas can outvote the entire rest of the country. Kris has plenty of fans in every state and he had a lot of fans at the concert last night. Seriously, I cannot believe you spend this much energy bashing a singer you don’t like. Wouldn’t it be much easier and more pleasant to concentrate on Adam or Allison or whoever you’re a fan of and just scroll past the Kris stuff?

      • Lisa

        Actually Dean Arkansas cannot outvote the rest of the country. They need AT&T’s help to do that

    • Kev

      You had to win the tickets.

      • media bias

        So what stopped KA fans from winning the tickets? The “winning” was based on voting then your email addy. Everyone did the same thing. Even KA’s mother was tweeting zip codes to people in freaking Brazil, go read her twats. KA fans won American Idol, so? Or did Adam fans suddenly develop some secret powers? And regarding the FAMILY, even Longineau had his fiance there. Next excuse? KA fans wanna dominate a concert, go ahead then and do it. Stop the whining already.

    • Elaine20

      We are confident enough about our guy to not feel the need to buy 30 copies each. But, thanks for the concern! BTW, even if Adam had won, HE’d be the lowest selling Idol.

      • jun

        i doubt that.

      • Men

        Really Elanie20? Why must you either attack any Adam fan or say things about Adam? If you are so confident in your Kris Allen there should be no need for your nasty remarks.

      • elaine20

        Men, I was simply answering a question that was asked about Kris Allen fans. What did I say about Adam in that answer?

      • Men

        Are you for real Elaine20? Your over fried brain cells done? I mean you forgot what you wrote that fast? You said this about Adam…..>>>>”even if Adam had won, HE’d be the lowest selling Idol”. How the hell would you know, you don’t like the guy, and unless you know things the rest of us don’t know then shut your pie hole.

      • elaine20

        Men, I don’t know Adam…How can I not like him? I stated a fact, that Adam’s sales to date have not matched any previous winner, thus even had he won, he would have the lowest sales. Why are you bothered by what I say? I’m one person on the internet, stating my opinion. Why don’t you skip my comments?

  • Suenee

    I am a David Cook fan. All I have to say is all of your bickering about who has the rudest fans is, you make the Cook/Archuleta fans look like saints. hehehe

    • Suenee

      let me rephrase that. All of your bickering about who has the rudest fans, makes Cook/Archuleta fans look like saints. hehehe

      • Deen

        Hah! So true! God bless Cook & Archie.

      • Lisa

        Cook and Archie don’t have Jim and Slezak pushing buttons and flaming the fan wars

    • media bias

      Yes but we see you on your board whining about Adam too. LOL last week one of you bumped a thread from last year whining that Adam stole the Mad World performance from Allison vis a vis Paula’s suggestion. You think we’re stupid? We research our stuff and know you ALL.

      • Men

        Media bias I just love you!

    • Wendy

      Haha NOT. I’ve been on the Cook fansite and I saw the Adam bashing and jealousy over Adam’s VH1 performance. Cook fans are just as bad.

      • Suenee

        Why so bitter? Adam is no threat to David. David has established him self in his genre, and is well liked and respected in the industry. There is no competition here. I say kuddos to all of them and wish them much success.

      • Jen

        Let me play your childish game-Cook sold more albums by this time last year AND won American Idol. More than I can say for King Lamebert. How is Clay Aiken’s career working out for him?

      • Men

        Jen you are so nasty girl. How is David Cook doing now? His second CD is not fairing so well. So? That is my point. I love me some David Cook but I also love “King Lambert”……you putting down Adam will not make him go away. How about you grow up?

      • Nickie

        David Cook has a second CD out already? I am a big fan and I didn’t know that. Are you for real? I miss something?

      • elaine20

        Men, butting in, maybe not so politely in your eyes. :)
        David Cook is currently writing for his second CD. I have no doubt it will be fantastic!!!

      • Nick

        If any of you here want to know the answer to any of your questions direct them towards Elaine20, she knows all and sees all!

      • elaine20

        My pleasure, Nick. But I’m not paying you a referral fee. :)

    • Cindy

      suenee, i was on a site last night, and it was over who had the “effect” that kara was talking about—and NEVER have i had a weird experience like i did on that site. my post did not show up, so i asked why, and all of a sudden, the site kept on appearing on my screen, over 20 times!!! i have used a computer for years, but i tell you this—-it was a cook site, others had similar experiences. yet, adam had over 50% of the vote for the poll. go figure. cook fans are not saints.

      • Amber

        I was on that same site and I am a Cook fan but my posts were not showing up either. I don’t know what the problem was but it was not just directed at Adam fans.

  • acb

    I don’t know why some people left early and neither do any of you. But I am a fainter and I cannot stand for more than an hour and a half before I pass out. Having been that way since middle school,I make a judgement when it is time to make an exit. I love Adam. I don’t dislike Kris but not really interested in him. I can tell you for sure that if I had been there, I would have been so out of there after Adam’s performance. Now if there were seating, I would stay for the entire concert even if Kris’s music does not interest me. You just can’t tell other people to stay if they don’t want to no matter what the reason is. If ya want to leave, you leave. Period. And somebody calling you rude will not change that.

    • Elaine20

      You just don’t get it! No one is telling other people to stay, but I for one, am calling them out for being rude and inconsiderate.
      Not ALL fans, but the ones defending the early departers are kind of moving into that group as well. Just sayin’.
      Oh, and bless your heart, I’m sorry about the fainting, but you KNOW that a third of the room weren’t all fainters. In fact, most of them stood all day waiting to get in, so I don’t think another 45 minutes would have tipped the scales on their part.

      • Nickie

        I don’t know why 45 minutes would have matter Elaine but you don’t either. Noone knows why people left. It didn’t seem to bother Kris, why does it bother you? I mean really? It might have been rude but why is it REALLY bothering you?

      • elaine20

        Nickie, we all have pet peeves. Mine is rudeness…simple as that.

      • Nickie

        If that is your pet peeve then mine is people who act like they are above others. I don’t know you Elaine20 and I won’t pretend I do by “bashing” you. But I don’t understand how what you are doing here is any different that what you are accusing others. I read all replies by you before I wrote this. My pet peeve is someone like you who hates rudeness but act the same way towards others. You are being rude to many on here because thier opinion might differ from yours. I don’t see how what you are doing different that what you accuse others of doing.

      • elaine20

        Nickie,
        All I’ve done is state my opinion. I thought that what they did was rude. How is that the same as purposely disrespecting someone who has done absolutely nothing to you? Who have I been rude to, and how? Is stating my opinion rude, even though everyone insists it was a small group that left, and they were the only ones I was referring to? I never called any names, swore, or dissed Adam in return for the many, many put downs toward Kris. A woman is writing a book for goodness sake!!
        I don’t think I’m above anyone. There are way too many factors in our make up for anyone to really better than others. I do know that in some ways, at least, I try to be more considerate.
        Honestly, I’ve seen Kris called just about everything, and his entire fan group called cheaters. deaf, boring, etc. Ignoring it just isn’t working and I’m afraid that people have felt free to “carry out their right to do what they please”, totally unheeded. Well, at least from this Kris fan, no more.

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 24
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP