Rock and Roll Hall of Fame 2011 inductees include Neil Diamond, Alice Cooper: who else made the cut?

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland will induct Tom Waits, Neil Diamond, Alice Cooper, Dr. John, and Darlene Love, according to the New York Times. Jac Holzman, who founded Elektra, and Art Rupe, who founded Specialty Records, will receive the Ahmet Ertegun Award, which is given to music-industry executives. Pianist Leon Russell will receive the Award for Musical Excellence. The ceremony will be held in March.

Comments (124 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 5
  • DN

    When KISS, Judas Priest, and Rush are inducted, this Hall will get respect from me (and Eddie Trunk of “That Metal Show”). Failing to recognize their influence on rock music is just plain failure.

    • Minutiae

      Had KISS made it before Alice Cooper, I might have staged a revolt myself. You wouldn’t have had KISS without Alice.

      • ks

        True

    • neetsie

      Hasn’t KISS already been inducted?

      • JimmyH

        No, KISS is not in the HOF.

      • Lovely Hearts

        Amazing band and ShortPeopleDate was perfect

    • Zawmer

      No group that claims to recognize quality rock music is legitimate if it routinely ignores Rush.

    • side3

      Is this Alice Cooper the indiviual, or “Alice Cooper” the band? It was the band that had the classic hits “School’s Out”, “No More Mr Nice Guy”, “I’m Eighteen” etc.

      I have to defend Neil Diamond. His 60′s and early 70′s records were pretty rocking. Also, he wrote some great songs covered by others like The Monkees’ “I’m A Believer” and “Look Out, Here Comes Tomorrow”, Deep Purple’s “Kentucky Woman” and UB40′s “Red Red Wine. really…”Thank the Lord for the Nighttime”, Cherry Cherry” etc are not rock?

      • NuckyT

        Here are some more-Korn & Staind recorded “Love on the Rocks”.HIM and Johnny Cash recorded “Solitary Man”.Phish recorded “Cracklin Rosie”.Dave Matthews and U2 recored “Sweet Caroline”.Weezer and Coldplay recorded “I’m A Believer”.

      • Shawnuel

        Correct. Neil was THE go-to hit writer in the mid 60′s.

    • Color Me Impressed

      Bands that really need to be inducted: The Replacements, Rush, Red Hot Chili Peppers and the Velvet Underground!

      • Steve Wilkison

        Velvets were inducted in 1996.

      • Shawnuel

        CMI I seem to agree with a lot of your opinions. Just not that Alice Cooper comment. Replacements and Husker Du need to be in the Hall. Also, Alex Chilton and T Bone Burnett.

  • JimmyH

    I’m with you DN. When Rush, Yes and E.L.P. are inducted I will care. KISS should have been inducted long ago.

  • rob

    well i suppose neil diamond was inevitable but the others are great choices

  • Elena

    Why in the hell are Neil DIamond Madonna, and ABBA in the RRHOF? No, I am not saying those artists have noo musical merit, and I know they have been hugely successful and influential. But what’s Rock and Roll about Dancing Queen, Like A Virgin and Sweet Caroline?

    • Turanga Leela

      I’m with you. Neil Diamond? Seriously? He’s not even much of a rock influence.

      • Libby

        Neil Diamond has more talent in his little finger than most of the singers out today…He’s the man!

    • C Men

      They need to just make it the Music Hall of Fame but then they couldn’t exclude rappers and hicks.

      • D’s Advocate

        They don’t exclude rappers.Probably don’t exclude hicks as well.

      • C Men

        They don’t? Well Music Hall of Fame it is!

      • Brenda Barrett

        If by ‘hicks,’ you mean country artists, then yes, artists like Hank Williams and Johnny Cash are in the Rock and Roll HOF. All told, I believe there are 11 artists who are in both the rock and country halls of fame — Brenda Lee is the only female solo artist in both.

    • PJ

      I would suggest doing some research on what rock and roll is before acting like you do.

    • Andy

      I’m still wondering why the hell he’s in the Last Waltz? He is not Rock and Roll.

      • Maga

        I am a rock n roll fan who likes everybody from System of a Down to Pink Floyd to the Ramones.Please educate me as to what rock n roll is if Neil Diamond in the Last Waltz (playing a song he wrote and recorded with half of the Band for his Beautiful Noise album) is not!

    • Maga

      You can apply that “What is Rock N Roll about” then mention their big pop hit to any hall of fame rock n roller.I find it nuts how you lump a Brill Building guitar playing singer songwriter who started in the 50′s with disco era Abba and Madonna.It is so ignorant.

      • Ian

        Amen, Maga. Glad someone here has some sense. I love when people are shocked that someone they don’t consider rock n’ roll is inducted, and they can’t understand the idea of rock n’ roll being more of an attitude than a genre. They can’t fathom someone like Neil Diamond being rock n’ roll, but at the same time they have no problem at all saying that Jerry Lee Lewis and The Clash are definitely the same genre. Get over it guys. People have different tastes and sensibilities, and a lot of the voters for the hall are musicians, so they have very wide ranges of taste and influence. Also after being in rock radio for quite some time, I can assure you that most musicians consider Kiss to be a complete joke. If there’s ever a merchandising hall of fame, they’ll have a shot at it, but for the most part the voters are much more inclined to induct Alice Cooper and Rush before Kiss ever gets in. Also consider that they have to induct 5 artists every year, so there will be a lot of weak groups of nominees and most borderline bands will eventually get in. Right now they’re still filling gaps of people not yet in who came LOOOOONG before Kiss. Hence the inductions of people like Neil Diamond and Darlene Love. You should also consider not giving a sh*t who’s in and who isn’t. It doesn’t dictate taste or quality, and it’s just a museum. Get over it and go turn the music up loud.

    • Color Me Impressed

      There are two kinds of people in this world: those that like Neil Diamonds, and those that don’t.

      • MsSuniDaze

        I see. So, what you’re saying is that even though you are an almost-paralyzed, multiphobic personality who is in a constant state of panic, your wife did not leave you, you left her because she… liked Neil Diamond?

    • Neil Diamond

      So you don’t have a problem then with the inductions of Michael Jackson, The Mama’s and Papa’s Beach Boys, & Beatles? They are all pop too…..

      • mike

        Valid point. People get so stuck on what rock and roll is. I mean, RUN DMC are not rock and roll either and people didn’t pitch a fit when they got in. (Must have been the duet with Aerosmith.)

    • Ed

      These pop artists are in the Rock and Roll HAll of Fame because pop music is a part of rock and roll. just like r&b, blues, rock, and rap!

    • Him

      Why would anyone doubt or question Madonna being inducted into the HOF? Her influence is unparalleled.

  • Dinana

    What about Chicago?

    • bringbackrocky

      Amen to that. They’ve been snubbed too many times.

    • tromba

      Double Amen!! Chicago invented an entire sub-genre and they have been kicking since the 60′s.

      • side3

        I would say Blood Sweat and Tears created that sub-genre…though Chicago was more successful.

      • dee

        Triple Amen! A travesty they are not in.

    • Libby

      Great band! I love Chicago!

    • Gary smith

      Chicago and Blood, Sweat, and Tears should both be in the HOF, but Chicago (the city and the band have never gotten the respect they deserve)

  • Damon

    Ch…still no Janet Jackson?

    • Tito

      Nasty!

  • Brandon

    Well….At least they put Waits in there. So any other oversight is forgiven.

    • Scott P

      Yeah, the Hall got a tiny bit more legitimate by adding Waits finally.

  • Brett

    Those of you who don’t recognize Neil Diamond’s contributions to rock and roll need to do more research.

    • Kathy

      Absolutely!! He was as influential on rock in the seventies as Elvis was on the sixties!!

    • NuckyT

      Neil Diamond was the first rocker to 1)Put out an african concept album long before Paul Simon 2)The first rocker to put out a live album in modern quadraphonic sound 3)The first successfull solo singer-songwriter to get that revolution rolling in the early 70′s 4)the first rocker to play broadway…I can go on an on.It is like judging the fat Elvis for the influence he had in his 20′s and 30′s.Totally unfair.

  • Larua

    What about the Moody Blues????

  • Sean

    All of you idiots complaining about Neil Diamond are idiots. Neil Diamond had just as much influence in 60′s and early 70′s in rock and roll as anyone else. The man was one of the great songwriters in the 60′s at the Brill Building with the likes of Carole King and then struck it out on his own with numerous Top 40 hits. Did he become a little cheesy in the 80′s? Absolutely. But for two decades he just as popular as any other artist during that time period.

    • Rick

      so true!!!

    • Mr T

      Yup, nothing says rock & roll like the name “Brill building”.

  • JoeC

    At last, Alice Cooper is in! As Eddie Trunk stated so eloquently, it should have been done the first year he was eligble, but better late than never! ‘I WANNA BE ELECTED!!!!!!!!’

  • JoeC

    And BTW, Alice is going in the same year as Neil Diamond?!?!? Perfect! They should perform together and do a medley of ‘No More Mr. Nice Guy’ and ‘Sweet Caroline’!!!!!

  • Kobolos

    KISS should have been inducted long ago, but Alice always should have been inducted first.

  • By-Tor

    No Rush = Epic Fail. Jann Wenner can bite me.

    • EVM

      Amen Tor…Saw them a few months ago and man they brought the house down! Seeing them again in March. Jann Wenner, Dave Marsh and Jon Landau, they’re to blame for the snub of the finest working mans band ever!

  • Anon

    WHAT HAPPENED TO BON JOVI????????????????????????

    • Templar

      Give them time. They’ll get there. I think a band or artist should reach has-been status before being recognized by the Hall. Since Bon Jovi has continuously top 10 grossing tours, they’re not ready to be considered statesmen of R&R. And they’re just now at the longevity point, KISS precedes them by at least 5 to 10 years. Let KISS in first.

    • Color Me Impressed

      Please no KISS, they absolutely blow…The Hall finally got some more cred by including Tom Waits, and I guess Alice Cooper is a decent choice, but still no Rush?! Wtf?! The one other group they need to include is The Replacements! Even though a lot of people don’t know who they are, they’ve been incredibly influential among other acclaimed rock musicians and their music and legacy is simply astounding. I’m gonna let the hall slide because this is the ‘Mats’ first year of eligability, but after this, I at least expect a nomination.

      • LOL

        KISS and the Replacements are not mutually exclusive. I happen to like both. There is room for each in the Hall.

Page: 1 2 3 5
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in Music

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP